Start selling with AliDrop today

Carvana was supposed to revolutionize car buying. With sleek vending machine-style towers, aggressive marketing campaigns, and a tech-forward business model, the company captured the imagination of a post-pandemic, e-commerce-hungry generation. The promise was bold: a digital, hassle-free car buying experience without the traditional dealership headaches.

But beneath this glitzy exterior, critics argue that Carvana’s foundation is riddled with debt, mismanagement, and deceit. With accusations ranging from fraudulent accounting practices to insider stock dumps and subprime lending schemes, Carvana is now under intense scrutiny from investors, regulators, and customers alike.

This blog dives into what Carvana really is, how it works, whether it is legit, and shares more details.

What is Carvana?

Carvana is an online used car retailer founded in 2012 and headquartered in Tempe, Arizona. The company aims to disrupt the traditional car dealership model by offering consumers the ability to shop, finance, and even trade in vehicles entirely online. Instead of haggling with salespeople, customers can browse a digital inventory, secure financing, and schedule delivery or pickup from one of Carvana’s signature car vending machines.

At its peak, Carvana was hailed as a “Netflix for cars.” The company’s marketing leaned heavily on convenience and transparency features often lacking in conventional car buying experiences. Its expansive logistics network allowed it to operate in hundreds of U.S. markets, boasting quick delivery turnarounds and flexible return policies.

Backed by venture capital and early investor enthusiasm, Carvana’s stock soared after its 2017 IPO. The company sold itself as a forward-thinking tech firm rather than a traditional auto retailer. But despite its branding, Carvana’s core operations—vehicle acquisitions, refurbishing, lending, and sales—remain capital-intensive and heavily reliant on consumer credit markets.

How Does Carvana Work?

Carvana simplifies the used car buying process by digitizing almost every step. Customers begin by browsing thousands of listings on the company’s website or app, filtering by make, model, price, mileage, and other features. Once a vehicle is selected, buyers can view 360-degree images, vehicle history reports, and price breakdowns. Carvana also offers a “no-haggle” pricing model, which it claims provides transparency and eliminates traditional dealership stress.

Next, users can apply for financing directly through Carvana. The company evaluates credit scores and income to offer instant loan decisions. Alternatively, buyers can use outside financing or pay in cash. Carvana even facilitates trade-ins by providing online appraisals, often sight-unseen.

After purchase, customers can schedule home delivery or pick up the vehicle from one of Carvana’s multi-story glass vending machines. Once the car arrives, customers get a seven-day trial period. If unsatisfied, they can return it for a full refund—another feature touted as revolutionary.

However, behind the scenes, Carvana manages vehicle sourcing, inspections, reconditioning, and logistics. It also owns its financing arm, which handles loans and bundles them into asset-backed securities. This complexity reveals that while the customer experience feels seamless, Carvana operates a heavily leveraged and intricate system.

Is Carvana Legit or a Scam?

On the surface, Carvana is a legitimate company. It’s publicly traded on the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE: CVNA), operates nationwide, and has delivered millions of vehicles to customers across the U.S. Its website functions, vehicles are real, and thousands of buyers have completed their purchases without issue. Yet, legitimacy doesn’t always mean ethical or sustainable; this is where the doubts emerge.

Numerous customers have reported severe issues with Carvana, ranging from undisclosed damage and mechanical failures to extended delays in vehicle registration. In some states, buyers have driven with expired temporary tags for months because Carvana failed to file paperwork in time. These registration failures have led to legal troubles for drivers and prompted state-level regulatory action. For instance, Carvana has had its dealer license suspended or threatened in multiple states, including Illinois and North Carolina.

The Hindenburg Research report takes the criticism further. It accuses Carvana of misleading accounting practices, insider stock dumping, and predatory subprime lending. If true, these claims suggest systemic risk, not just isolated incidents.

So, is Carvana a scam? Not in the traditional, outright fraudulent sense. But its alleged manipulation of financial data, insider enrichment during decline, and consumer service failures reveal a pattern that many argue is deeply unethical—if not illegal. While it may not be a scam by definition, critics insist it's not the consumer-first innovation it claims to be, but a precarious business model dressed in digital convenience.

Who is Ernie Garcia?

Central to Carvana’s story is Ernie Garcia II, the convicted felon often referred to as the company’s “puppet master.” Though his son, Ernie Garcia III, is the official CEO, many argue that the elder Garcia continues to wield significant influence from behind the scenes through his direct involvement and his control of related entities like DriveTime.

Garcia II’s checkered past dates back to the 1980s savings and loan scandal, one of the largest financial frauds in U.S. history. He pleaded guilty to bank fraud for his role in the Lincoln Savings and Loan collapse, which bilked investors out of millions. While he avoided a lengthy prison sentence by cooperating with authorities, his reputation never recovered in professional finance circles.

Yet Garcia managed to re-emerge in the automotive finance industry. He built DriveTime, a subprime car loan company targeting high-risk borrowers, and later helped launch Carvana as a spin-off. Through complex ownership structures and shared operations, Garcia II has remained closely tied to Carvana’s operations, raising concerns about transparency and governance.

Critics argue that Garcia’s continued presence taints Carvana’s claims of innovation and ethics. The Hindenburg report questions why a company with such a storied founder has drawn little regulatory scrutiny until recently. For many investors and consumers, knowing that a convicted financial criminal is linked to a major retail operation, especially one dealing in loans and debt, is more than troubling; it’s a red flag waving in plain sight.

Carvana’s Biggest Secrets in Accounting and Financial Fraud

Carvana’s impressive revenue numbers have often been touted as signs of innovation and success. But according to the Hindenburg Research report, these figures may be more illusion than reality. The company’s debt has ballooned to over $8 billion—a staggering number for a relatively young operation. To investors, Carvana paints a picture of rapid growth and rising profitability. In practice, critics say it relies heavily on aggressive accounting maneuvers to appear solvent.

One method cited is the manipulation of delivery costs. Instead of classifying vehicle shipping and logistics as operational expenses, Carvana allegedly shifts these costs into other categories to artificially inflate gross profit per vehicle. At one point, the company claimed earnings of over $7,000 per car, which raised eyebrows across the auto industry, where the average is far lower.

Even more concerning is the bundling and resale of subprime auto loans (discussed further in the next section). By booking revenue immediately upon sale but deferring costs or losses related to loan defaults, Carvana creates the illusion of a healthier balance sheet than exists.

Such tactics may not be illegal, but they echo the financial engineering that preceded past corporate collapses—Enron, Lehman Brothers, and others. Critics argue that Carvana’s books are not designed to reflect reality but to maximize stock valuation and mislead shareholders. These accusations have intensified as stock prices have plunged and the company’s cash burn accelerates.

In short, the numbers look good on paper, but beneath the surface, Carvana is drowning in a sea of leveraged risk and unsustainable financial practices.

Carvana’s Business Model and Loans

One of the most alarming aspects of Carvana’s business model is its dependence on subprime auto lending. Subprime borrowers—those with low credit scores and high risk of default—make up a significant portion of Carvana’s customer base. Some estimates suggest that nearly half Carvana’s buyers owe more on their vehicles than the cars are worth. This mirrors the reckless lending behavior that led to the 2008 housing crash.

Carvana not only originates loans for these high-risk customers through its in-house financing division, but also packages and sells them as asset-backed securities to investors. While this tactic allows Carvana to recoup cash quickly and move risk off its balance sheet, it burdens the broader financial system. Investors take on the risk of defaults, while Carvana reaps short-term gains.

The Hindenburg report directly compares to the subprime mortgage crisis, warning that auto loan delinquencies are now surpassing even pre-2008 levels. This isn’t just a red flag for Carvana—it’s a systemic issue that could destabilize parts of the auto finance industry. If defaults continue to rise, these bundled securities could collapse in value, triggering losses for institutional investors and banks alike.

The concern is compounded by the fact that Carvana’s underwriting practices may prioritize volume over quality. In a race to grow market share, the company risks creating a debt bubble that it cannot sustain. While the profits from these loans may look good in quarterly earnings, the long-term consequences could be catastrophic for Carvana and the financial markets tied to its lending portfolio.

Insider Stock Dumping: Profiting from Collapse

While Carvana’s financial footing deteriorated and its stock value plummeted, executives and insiders were cashing out. According to Hindenburg Research, CEO Ernie Garcia III and other top shareholders sold off over $1.4 billion in company stock just as cracks in the business model began to show. This selloff occurred while public investors were still sold the idea of unstoppable growth, raising serious concerns about insider knowledge and ethical governance.

The timing was hardly coincidental. These massive stock sales began shortly before Carvana’s share price began a steep decline, just as the company’s debt reached unsustainable levels. While selling stock isn’t illegal, such large-scale divestments during periods of financial stress often signal something far more troubling: a lack of faith in the company’s future from those who know it best.

Critics argue that these stock dumps are tantamount to jumping ship while the passengers—customers, employees, and shareholders—remain unaware that the vessel is sinking. In the context of the broader accusations in the Hindenburg report, the insider transactions look less like ordinary financial planning and more like opportunistic profiteering.

This behavior undermines investor confidence and raises questions about transparency and accountability. If company leadership profits while value collapses and customers suffer, it casts doubt on Carvana’s commitment to long-term sustainability or ethical responsibility. For many, these insider moves are not just red flags but alarm bells.

Quality Issues and Customer Nightmares

As Carvana scaled its operations at breakneck speed, quality control and customer support began to unravel. Numerous reports from buyers detail cars arriving with undisclosed mechanical problems, structural damage, missing parts, or faulty repairs. In one case, a customer claimed their newly purchased vehicle had over $100,000 in prior damage that was glossed over during the sale. Others have reported being forced to replace tires or shocks within weeks of delivery.

More alarming are the widespread complaints about registration delays. In several states, customers waited months—sometimes over a year—to receive proper documentation, leaving them to drive illegally or park their vehicles while still making loan payments. These issues have led to real-world consequences: arrests, impounded vehicles, and massive consumer frustration.

Carvana’s once-celebrated customer service has deteriorated under the strain. Phone support is often unresponsive, delayed case resolutions, and some buyers claim they were ghosted entirely after reporting issues. Regulatory agencies have taken note; several states have suspended or threatened to revoke Carvana’s license to operate due to registration violations and deceptive practices.

Conclusion

Carvana’s rise and unraveling tell a broader story about unchecked disruption, financial manipulation, and the dangers of prioritizing growth over governance. What began as a tech-driven promise to transform car buying has exposed deep-rooted ethical lapses and systemic financial risks. As regulators close in and consumer trust erodes, Carvana is a stark warning: not every disruptor is a savior—some are simply old scams in new packaging.